It’s taking over America. The New York Times reports on how hockey is joining baseball, football, and soccer in the schedules and lives of American children.
One woman frankly admits that, “We see these people [other hockey parents] a lot more than we see our other friends.”
First, that makes the hockey people your friends. Those other people, the ones you don’t see anymore because you’re spending all your time buying $300 skates and sticks for your 8-year old? They aren’t really your friends anymore. Sorry.
Second, the hell?
When did organized sports for kids become so…organized? And is this fun for kids anymore? Not long ago, the New York Times published an article about a sports camp-cum-school for young athletes who show promise and need to spend more time practicing and less time hanging out with friends. The big fear? That playing on a school team, or just kicking/hitting a ball around in someone’s backyard might instill bad habits that would have to be trained out. (I.e., an 11-year old is going to develop a bad pitching form unless he has an $80,000/year coach showing him how to do it.)
That article made another point: all the overtraining is taking some of the purity out of a young player’s talent. The spontenaity is gone, and these kids start to look the same—same form, same timing, same, same. And yet, one family profiled in that article had sold their home to move there so their son could train 8 hours a day—and attend the attached school for 5 hours a day.
That’s wrong in one way, and I hope I don’t have to spell it out.
But what I’m really on right now is the overscheduling of kids.
I was involved in afterschool activities when I was a kid—I took ballet and, in high school, was in school plays and my church choir. I was active and had stuff to do—because I wanted stuff to do. It was fun for me. I don’t remember ever having a sense that I had to go to ballet, except during recital rehearsals, because I had committed to being in the performance. Ditto for plays and choir.
I also remember that, on the days I didn’t have ballet, I wanted things to do after school besides do homework and watch TV, so when I got too bored with my brother, I’d go hang out with some of the kids on my street. We’d jump on the trampoline one of them had. Even when I spent much of my afterschool time at the ballet studio, I spent it doing homework and hanging out with the other girls who weren’t in class and we had fun there, too. We were there because we liked dance. Even the most intense dancers would still walk down to the fast-food place and get an apple pie and vanilla shake with the rest of us. It was fun.
My brothers and cousins were all involved in team sports at our school, and they had practices before and after school, but it was always fun for them. When it stopped being fun for my brother, he quit the tennis team and got a job.
All of this is to say that I remember organized sports and afterschool activities being about fun. They were also about learning teamwork, growing as leaders, and all of the things that organized sports have always been about for kids. But they were never about being “the best” or about planning to go pro out of high school. (Sure, we all wanted to be good, and win championships or prizes, but that’s part of any competitive activity.) And certainly certainly, my brothers and cousins did not spend all their time at the school or the gym, practicing, and they definitely didn’t drag their parents and younger siblings around with them.
I see this trend, now, that every second of a child’s life has to be planned, down to the minute, and I wonder what time that leaves for picnics in the backyard and lemonade stands and duels with branches (all things I did as a child, not that long ago). WIth the loss of unscheduled time comes a loss of spontaneity, freedom to imagine, and serendipity. Where is the space for a child to write short stories and poems, or to paint portraits of the family pets?
I hope that when I am a parent, I can remember to leave space for my kids to do nothing, to follow their imaginations, to manage themselves and figure out what makes them tick. And I hope that those times they spend inside themselves will lead them to the passions they’ll feel and follow the rest of their lives. Because what I see is that when organized sports and activities become less about learning and fun and more about competition and perfection, we all lose a little something from the future.